I love football. And I love music. I am also quite fond of the Material Girl. But in the 2012 Superbowl? Madonna was just terrible.
The game itself was great and I thought that the better team won. But is was a nail-biting seesaw match which was decided in the game’s final moments.
But let’s talk about the halftime show. Recent years have brought us some amazing halftime shows by great rock and roll bands. The Rolling Stones and the Who were a bunch of guys in their 60s when they appeared in the Superbowl but both bands put on a great show. Everyone remembers U2′s appearance in the wake of the 9-11 tragedy when they showed all the names of the people who were killed in the terrorist attack. And who can forget Janet Jackson’s costume malfunction?
Which takes me to Madonna. Instead of letting her music speak for her, Madonna hid behind a mountain of kitschy pyrotechnic effects. She didn’t even perform! Instead she pre-recorded the songs and lip-synched them on stage. How phony is that? I don’t think that Madonna is too old. Like I said before, the Stones, McCartney and the Who were all much older than her when they performed at Superbowls. And Madonna can still dance like the devil. But isn’t being a musician about music, not just fancy lighting and stage affects? And shouldn’t a live music performance be just that? Live music by live performers? Madonna blew it, she failed to produce the goods. And it’s a shame because she had the biggest stage in the world to prove that she’s still got it.




